star ratings problem when using sidecars

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
3 messages Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

star ratings problem when using sidecars

Philip Tuckey-2
I have dk set to write metadata to xmp sidecars only.
In 5.0.0 (on OSX) and 4.14.0 (ubuntu) I see the following behaviour:
dk always writes the line
    xmp:Rating="4"
to the xmp sidecar, independently of the star rating of the image.
Changing the star rating does not change this line.
In contrast, the "acdsee:rating" and "MicrosoftPhoto:Rating" lines are
set correctly.
This messes up the star ratings if ever metadata is re-read from the
image (sidecar).
Does anyone else see the same thing?
Thanks
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: star ratings problem when using sidecars

Philip Tuckey-2
On further investigation, I can't reproduce this behaviour on images
which don't already have the problem. But somehow a number of my
sidecars have become corrupted in the way I described.

On 08/08/16 20:50, Phil wrote:

> I have dk set to write metadata to xmp sidecars only.
> In 5.0.0 (on OSX) and 4.14.0 (ubuntu) I see the following behaviour:
> dk always writes the line
>    xmp:Rating="4"
> to the xmp sidecar, independently of the star rating of the image.
> Changing the star rating does not change this line.
> In contrast, the "acdsee:rating" and "MicrosoftPhoto:Rating" lines are
> set correctly.
> This messes up the star ratings if ever metadata is re-read from the
> image (sidecar).
> Does anyone else see the same thing?
> Thanks
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: star ratings problem when using sidecars

Philip Tuckey-2
After further investigation, it appears that if any of the following
keywords are set in the image file (always a jpeg in my case):
IPTC:CopyrightNotice
IPTC:By-line
IPTC:Contact
then the error in writing xmp:Rating to the sidecar occurs.

Both my dk 5.0.0 and 4.14.0 use exiv2 0.25.

I did not have this behaviour with older dk, say 0.4.6. I don't know
which exiv2 version that was using.

On 08/08/16 21:35, Phil wrote:

> On further investigation, I can't reproduce this behaviour on images
> which don't already have the problem. But somehow a number of my
> sidecars have become corrupted in the way I described.
>
> On 08/08/16 20:50, Phil wrote:
>> I have dk set to write metadata to xmp sidecars only.
>> In 5.0.0 (on OSX) and 4.14.0 (ubuntu) I see the following behaviour:
>> dk always writes the line
>>    xmp:Rating="4"
>> to the xmp sidecar, independently of the star rating of the image.
>> Changing the star rating does not change this line.
>> In contrast, the "acdsee:rating" and "MicrosoftPhoto:Rating" lines are
>> set correctly.
>> This messes up the star ratings if ever metadata is re-read from the
>> image (sidecar).
>> Does anyone else see the same thing?
>> Thanks