Hi,
I tested digikam svn 0,9 and I see that when switching to the next preview I get a blinking "preview extration in progress". I do not think that it is a good idea. The blinking effect attract the attention to the exact thing you do not want the user to feel : it takes time ... The best implementation I have seen yet. is the one in eofg or showfoto with a progress bar, if is not pssible I would suggest writing the "preview extraction in progress " under or over the image instead of taking the image away. Concerning the "back to album" and edit". Why not... but what do you think of putting them as a toolbar on the top left as icon or ttext ? it would be more consistent with the rest of the interface (prev and next are at the top left in the properties sidebar and the toolbars are on the top too ) Olivier _______________________________________________ Digikam-devel mailing list [hidden email] https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/digikam-devel |
Le Vendredi 14 Juillet 2006 21:51, Olivier a écrit :
> Hi, > I tested digikam svn 0,9 and I see that when switching to the next preview > I get a blinking "preview extration in progress". I do not think that it is > a good idea. The blinking effect attract the attention to the exact thing > you do not want the user to feel : it takes time ... But it can take time is the picture do not have an embedded preview data to show. Let's me explain exactly how this part work: Some picture file format use preview image embedded in metadata. RAW file like NEF, MRW, or CR2 use this in makernaote area. The preview is generaly a JPEG or TIF or PPM small image (1024*768 for example). It's not the Exif thumbnail ! It's a preview used by camera to show the image on a TV screen for slideshow. It's different. This way is very fast to load image data instead the whole image... In JPEG, the same way is used by camera (makernote preview). About TIFF and PNG, there is generally no preview recorded. But with 0.9.0-svn, digiKam use the IPTC preview tag to store a small JPEG preview image (800x600) to render preview extraction in a fast way. This is only done when you edit a picture, and your save it. > The best implementation I have seen yet. is the one in eofg or showfoto > with a progress bar, if is not pssible Is not possible because i don't have a progress feedback from the preview extractor kioslave. The Showfoto/Image Editor loading part is completly different and of course can do it. > I would suggest writing the "preview > extraction in progress " under or over the image instead of taking the > image away. Hum this is my proposal : delayed the blink effect (for example 500ms). If a preview is found, nothing will appear. If no preview is available, the whole image is loaded and it can take a while. In this case the blink effect will apppear... If you is agree with this rule, please make a new file in B.K.O, we will do it later the first beta1, because we have planed to do this release during next week with Marcel, and we try to fix the last know bugs actually. > > Concerning the "back to album" and edit". Why not... but what do you think > of putting them as a toolbar on the top left as icon or ttext ? it would be > more consistent with the rest of the interface (prev and next are at the > top left in the properties sidebar and the toolbars are on the top too ) This need to be discuted with the rest of users/developpers. Make a new file in B.KO again about this point. Thanks in advance for your report. Gilles. _______________________________________________ Digikam-devel mailing list [hidden email] https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/digikam-devel |
Caulier Gilles wrote: > >> The best implementation I have seen yet. is the one in eofg or showfoto >> with a progress bar, if is not pssible > > Is not possible because i don't have a progress feedback from the preview > extractor kioslave. The Showfoto/Image Editor loading part is completly > different and of course can do it. > What about a fake one ? using a timer or arbitratry %. 10 before opening, 40 after reading, 60 after resize ? This does not give more informations than blinking but makes the UI consistent with showfoto and is less invasive. (btw the progress bar in eog seems to be fake but feels good ) _______________________________________________ Digikam-devel mailing list [hidden email] https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/digikam-devel |
In reply to this post by Gilles Caulier-2
Caulier Gilles wrote:
> >> The best implementation I have seen yet. is the one in eofg or showfoto >> with a progress bar, if is not pssible > > Is not possible because i don't have a progress feedback from the preview extractor kioslave. The Showfoto/Image Editor loading part is completly different and of course can do it. > What about a fake one ? using a timer or arbitratry %. 10 before opening, 40 after reading, 60 after resize ? This does not give more informations than blinking but makes the UI consistent with showfoto and is less invasive. (btw the progress bar in eog seems to be fake but feels good ) _______________________________________________ Digikam-devel mailing list [hidden email] https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/digikam-devel |
Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |